Salesforce, Inc.

Salesforce, Inc. Q4 FY2020 earnings

CRM

Quarter ended Jan 2020.

← Q3 FY2020Q1 FY2021 →
Revenue
$4.85B
+34.6% YoY
Gross margin
74.8%
+1.1 pp YoY
Operating margin
-0.7%
-4.5 pp YoY
Net income
-$248.0M
-168.5% YoY

Summary

Salesforce reported fourth quarter revenue of $4.85 billion, up 34.6% from the prior-year quarter. Full fiscal year revenue was $17.10 billion, up 28.7%. Gross profit was $3.63 billion in the quarter, up 36.7%, and gross margin was 74.9%, up 1.1 percentage points. Full year gross profit was $12.86 billion, up 30.8%, with gross margin of 75.2%, up 1.2 percentage points. The company closed several acquisitions during fiscal 2020, including Tableau, ClickSoftware and Salesforce.org. Those deals expanded the product portfolio and contributed to the revenue base.

Profitability was the weak spot. The quarter produced an operating loss of $36.0 million, down from the prior-year quarter, and operating margin was -0.7%, down 4.5 percentage points. Net loss was $248.0 million, down from the prior-year quarter, and diluted loss per share was $0.28, down from the prior-year quarter. For the full year, operating income was $297 million, down 44.5%, net income was $126 million, down 88.6%, and diluted earnings per share was $0.15, down 89.5%. Non-GAAP diluted earnings per share was $0.66 in the quarter and $2.99 for the full year. The gap between GAAP and non-GAAP results reflects large non-cash charges, including stock-based expense and amortization of purchased intangibles. Management continues to invest heavily in growth, and that spending is weighing on GAAP profitability.

Cash generation remained solid. Fourth quarter operating cash flow was $1.63 billion, up 22.6%, and full year operating cash flow was $4.33 billion, up 27.5%. Capital expenditures were $136 million in the quarter, down 18.6%, and $643 million for the full year, up 8.1%. Deferred revenue was $10.66 billion, up 24.5%. Total remaining performance obligation was $30.8 billion, up 19.8%. Full time equivalent headcount was 49,703 at January 31, 2020, up from 35,995 a year earlier. Attrition, excluding Commerce Cloud, Integration Cloud, Salesforce.org and Tableau, was less than nine percent as of January 31, 2020.

Guidance points to slower growth but still healthy expansion. For the first quarter of fiscal 2021, Salesforce guided revenue to $4.875 billion to $4.885 billion, up 30% to 31% year over year. For the full fiscal year 2021, revenue guidance is $21.0 billion to $21.1 billion, up 23%. First quarter GAAP earnings per share guidance is $0.00 to $0.01, and non-GAAP earnings per share guidance is $0.70 to $0.71. Full fiscal year 2021 GAAP earnings per share guidance is $0.12 to $0.14, and non-GAAP earnings per share guidance is $3.16 to $3.18. The company also guided full fiscal year 2021 operating cash flow growth of 20% and first quarter current remaining performance obligation growth of 23% to 24%. Salesforce agreed to acquire Vlocity for approximately $1.33 billion, a deal expected to close in the second quarter of fiscal 2021. The guidance assumes no change to the value of the strategic investment portfolio and uses a non-GAAP tax rate of 22%.

Risks are mounting. The coronavirus outbreak has already shifted some customer events to virtual-only formats, and management said the effect may not be fully reflected in results until future periods. Foreign currency fluctuations negatively impacted fiscal 2020 revenue. The company also flagged a potential one-time income tax charge tied to integrating ClickSoftware and other Israeli entities, based on an assumed Israeli statutory tax rate of 23%. Salesforce faces integration risk from its recent acquisitions, including Tableau, ClickSoftware and Vlocity. Longer and less predictable sales cycles, competition in cloud computing, and data security concerns remain ongoing risks. The company also noted that its fourth quarter is historically its strongest for new business and renewals, which can make sequential comparisons uneven.

Forecast

Management guidance
ReportedGuidance

Guided revenue, Q1 FY2021$4.875B – $4.885B
Midpoint$4.88B
Growth vs Q4 FY2020+0.6%
Growth vs Q1 FY2020+30.6%
Q1 FY21
Revenue Growth (Y/Y)30% - 31%
GAAP earnings per share$0.00 - $0.01
Non-GAAP earnings per share$0.70 - $0.71
Current Remaining Performance Obligation Growth (Y/Y)23% - 24%
Full Year FY21
Revenue$21.0 - $21.1 billion
Revenue Growth (Y/Y)23%
GAAP earnings per share$0.12 - $0.14
Non-GAAP earnings per share$3.16 - $3.18
Operating Cash Flow Growth (Y/Y)20%

Reported figures

GAAP, from SEC filings
MetricQ4 FY2020Q3 FY2020QoQQ4 FY2019YoY
Revenue$4.85B$4.51B+7.5%$3.60B+34.6%
Gross profit$3.63B$3.38B+7.5%$2.66B+36.7%
Gross margin74.8%74.9%-0.0 pp73.7%+1.1 pp
Research & development$831.0M$774.0M+7.4%$518.0M+60.4%
Sales & marketing$2.35B$2.06B+13.7%$1.64B+42.8%
General & administrative$490.0M$477.0M+2.7%$359.0M+36.5%
Total operating expenses$3.67B$3.31B+10.7%$2.52B+45.5%
Operating income (loss)-$36.0M$65.0M-155.4%$137.0M-126.3%
Operating margin-0.7%1.4%-2.2 pp3.8%-4.5 pp
Net income (loss)-$248.0M-$109.0M-127.5%$362.0M-168.5%
Net margin-5.1%-2.4%-2.7 pp10.1%-15.2 pp
Diluted EPS-$0.29-$0.12-$0.17$0.47-$0.76

Risks

HIGHCoronavirus

The filing states the ongoing Coronavirus epidemic could disrupt customer, employee and industry events, sales cycles, vendors and IT spending, and MD&A notes the extent of impact on financial condition or results is uncertain. Salesforce shifted certain customer events to virtual-only experiences and may alter, postpone or cancel additional events.

HIGHAcquisition Integration

Fiscal 2020 included Tableau for $14.8 billion, ClickSoftware for $1.4 billion and Salesforce.org for $300 million, and MD&A says integration and equity award expenses reduced operating income. Risks include failure to achieve benefits, security vulnerabilities in acquired products, retention of acquired employees, and regulatory remedies such as the UK CMA review of Tableau.

HIGHMargin Pressure

Fiscal 2020 operating income was $297 million, down 44.5% year over year, and net income was $126 million, down 88.6%, while Q4 swung to an operating loss of $36 million and a net loss of $248 million. MD&A attributes pressure to significant equity award and purchased intangible amortization expenses from acquisitions.

HIGHSales Cycle

MD&A highlights longer and less predictable sales cycles and increasing business complexity from an expanded product mix and varied revenue models. Risk factors say larger enterprise and government sales require more configuration, integration and education, can delay revenue recognition, and may increase costs.

HIGHTalent Retention

In February 2020 Keith Block resigned as co-CEO and director, and the filing says such executive changes may be disruptive. Salesforce also depends on key development and operations personnel and faces competition for engineers, sales executives and data scientists.

HIGHPrivacy Regulation

The CCPA took effect in January 2020 and GDPR imposes obligations on Salesforce as both data controller and processor, with evolving cross-border transfer limits and data residency laws. The filing says these can reduce demand, require contract changes, increase penalties and slow sales transactions.

MEDIUMAI Ethics

Salesforce is increasingly building AI into offerings and says AI and Customer 360 present emerging ethical issues that could cause brand or reputational harm, competitive harm or legal liability. Data practices that draw controversy could impair acceptance of AI solutions.

MEDIUMService Disruption

In fiscal 2020 Salesforce experienced a significant service disruption from an internally deployed software update and disabled access for potentially impacted customers while remediating. The filing says future defects or disruptions could harm reputation, cause non-renewal or payment delays, and increase liabilities.

MEDIUMStrategic Investments

Salesforce records fair value adjustments of public and private equity investments through the statement of operations, and gains on strategic investments, net were $427 million in fiscal 2020 versus $542 million in fiscal 2019. This can create material quarterly volatility and may cause the stock price to decline.

MEDIUMTax

Fiscal 2020 had a tax provision of $580 million on pretax income of $706 million, an effective tax rate of 82%, driven by integration of acquired operations and profitable non-U.S. jurisdictions. The filing also flags a potential one-time Israeli tax charge related to ClickSoftware integration.

MEDIUMDebt

As of January 31, 2020 Salesforce had $2.5 billion carrying value of senior unsecured notes due 2023 and 2028 plus $193 million of 50 Fremont secured notes, and new lease accounting increased operating and finance lease liabilities. Covenants, refinancing risk and higher interest rates could adversely affect financial condition.

MEDIUMCompetition

The market is intensely competitive and fragmented, with competitors including packaged software vendors, internally developed applications, free or low-cost software, analytics, integration, marketing, e-commerce, platform and AI solutions. Some competitors have greater resources, larger customer bases and distribution agreements.

MEDIUMAttrition

Customers have no obligation to renew subscriptions typically after 12 to 36 months, and Salesforce has less experience forecasting renewal rates for term software license sales added through MuleSoft and Tableau. Attrition excluding Commerce Cloud, Integration Cloud, Salesforce.org and Tableau was less than nine percent as of January 31, 2020.

MEDIUMForeign Currency

Foreign currency fluctuations, primarily the strengthening British Pound Sterling, negatively impacted fiscal 2020 revenues outside the Americas by approximately $91 million. MD&A says fluctuations negatively impacted fiscal 2020 revenue results and are expected to continue.

MEDIUMInfrastructure

Salesforce relies on third-party data center hosting, cloud platform providers and hardware and software vendors, and the filing says the ongoing Coronavirus epidemic could disrupt the supply chain of hardware needed to maintain these systems. Interruptions could cause credits, penalties, customer terminations and reduced revenue.

Remaining Performance Obligation
approximately $30.8 billion (+20% YoY)
Current Remaining Performance Obligation
approximately $15.0 billion (+26% YoY, 27% in constant currency)
Billings and other (Q4)
$8,667 million
Free cash flow (Q4)
$1,496 million
Attrition rate (as of Jan 31, 2020, excluding Commerce Cloud, Integration Cloud, Salesforce.org and Tableau)
less than 9%

Current remaining performance obligation (cRPO)

33 quarters
$15.00B
Q4 FY2020+17.2%

Free cash flow

29 quarters
$1.50B
Q4 FY2020+419.4%

Remaining performance obligation (RPO)

29 quarters
$30.80B
Q4 FY2020+18.9%

Billings and other

25 quarters
$8.67B
Q4 FY2020+123.0%

Attrition Rate

9 quarters
~9%
Q4 FY2020-1.0pp

Summary, forecast, risks and KPIs are extracted from Salesforce, Inc.'s SEC filings for Q4 FY2020 (10-Q / 10-K and the 8-K earnings release); GAAP figures in the summary are checked against the reported XBRL data. They can contain errors; the filings are authoritative. Processed Oct 21, 2026.